Carol Macaluso - Testimonials

Tell Us Your Story

Reviews on Zillow
Average Rating
(View all 15 reviews)
"Carol worked tirelessly to find us the home of our dreams. She was available day or night to answer and questions or concerns we had and she worked diligently with the bank and the lawyers to get the process completed quickly and correctly."
5 /5.0
by Jennifer
"Carol is absolutely fantastic! She's has intimate knowledge of the market, and is incredibly helpful in guiding you through the entire home-buying process, from pre-approval to closing. She proved to be an invaluable resource at every stage of the process, and was an integral part of my "A-Team"! It's a pleasure to recommend her to future buyers! She's literally the best!"
5 /5.0
by fkmoylan
"My husband and I used Carol for both the sale of our previous home and then purchase of our current home. We searched for 9 months before finding our new home and she searched tirelessly on our behalf. She was knowledgeable, always responsive and truly a pleasure to work with. She made both transactions easy for us! We cannot recommend her highly enough!"
5 /5.0
by ccesarino83
"Carol was very helpful! She made herself available at all times, including night time and weekends. She was very proactive in helping me find a home, and again she made herself available to move the process along and to answer all questions I had about things. As a first time homeowner, I was grateful to have Carol's expertise and enthusiasm."
5 /5.0
by zuser20181016115850452
"Meeting Carol was a god blessing. My wife and I called her office for a listing we saw online and she sounded so sweet, knowledgable and confident she can help us. Within the first couple of minutes of meeting her, she welcomed us with both a heartwarming smile and a portfolio of the listing we were about see, recent and local comps, and a small gift for meeting with her. After one walk thru, we were inseparable for the next couple of months as we immediately decided to let Carol find us the house of our dreams while navigating this crazy post-Covid housing market. I implore anyone reading this that Carol, will sweep away any competition you had in finding a realtor, and you can rest at ease that you’re in the right hands. Carol was so patient that we must have viewed around 30 or more houses and still waited on us hand and foot. I have been at closing tables and have negotiated and bought houses prior to using Carol, and will never want her to not represent me. The only con was that she found our Forever home and thus we won’t be weekend house seeing buddies anymore, but now life-long friends. She not only found our new forever home, but also sold our existing home, came by with her husband to support a fundraiser I was having. She is a woman of integrity, professionalism, and poise; and hands down the best realtor I have ever had. As elaborate and too amazing this review may sound, I was not paid to write these things and this is the true honest statement from a first time and now forever client."
5 /5.0
by jmelcabe
"I have only fabulous things to say in regards to Carol. She handled everything with the utmost attention to every last detail. She is always 3 steps ahead during the entire process moving forward - solving potential snags before they even present themselves. Whether you’re selling or buying - this is who you want representing you."
5 /5.0
by ssspinky
"Carol was on top of every detail and very good at her job! She also is ver persistent which is key in selling a home. She also knows the value of homes in the community. I highly recommend her!"
5 /5.0
by aesposito56
"I felt like I was seeing homes with a family member. Carol was very friendly and professional. Every time I called with questions she was available. Every time I emailed her she quickly responded. She got me in my house the before the Open House as it just came on the market. It was a nice surprise and wound up becoming my home. When it's time to move on I'm calling Carol."
5 /5.0
by zuser20141029113015456
"We highly recommend Carol Macaluso as a seller’s agent. She was extremely knowledgeable about the market trends and helped us list/sell our house with ease. Carol is attentive to the customer’s needs and has insight to help with informed decision-making in all aspects with selling a home."
5 /5.0
by LoriMcAndrew9
"I’ll start with the fact that Carol Macaluso is incredible to work with! My husband and I recently bought a house on the south shore of Long Island and Carol knows the market well. We were transparent with Carol that we were not in a rush and wanted to find the home that felt right- she was by our sides the entire time, but never made us feel pressured. She is extremely knowledgeable about the process and is very flexible. We both work in the city so weekends were best and Carol made time for us each weekend this Spring to bounce along the south shore and check Sout houses. We had a wonderful experience and would highly recommend working with Carol."
5 /5.0
by elgross8
Zillow Logo

Property Search

Fair Housing Icon NY Fair Housing Notice